Which Car Battery is Best? Let's find out!


Comments • 8 339

  • umac76
    umac76  43 minutes back

    I don't understand the rationale of recommending batteries that you didn't test.

    • Miguel Collazo
      Miguel Collazo  2 hours back

      Thank you for this lesson on batteries. I learned a lot , nice know the difference about batteries. I need to purchase a new one so to Walmart I go.

      • Bake been
        Bake been  4 hours back

        What do you do with all the batteries you buy?

        • CanadianBullFrog
          CanadianBullFrog  6 hours back

          Too bad you don't have any Canadian Tire batteries...

          • chief 1 redwolf
            chief 1 redwolf  8 hours back

            All good gifts and perfect gifts comes down from the Father of lights in who there is no variableness or shadow or turning Jesus said . And that faith comes by hearing and hearing by the Word of God. We must be willing to turn from sin and self to receive Jesus forgiveness. And to know and live out his. KJV, NKJV, NASB.

            • Howard
              Howard  10 hours back

              Your tests are certainly thorough, but you are testing new batteries. Automotive batteries are no longer made with solid lead plates, but with recycled lead powder attached to some kind of plate. I would be willing to bet your top two batteries wouldn't even rate if they were a year or two old.

              • Joe Smith
                Joe Smith  10 hours back

                i use super start cause i got commercial account at oreilys and get discount and they deliver. and its easy to look up battery on my account for warranty. and they warrantied couple they werent supposed to just cause i was good commercial customer.

                • frank black
                  frank black  10 hours back

                  Thanks project farm for the info

                  • Strugls
                    Strugls  11 hours back

                    Uh -14 Celsius in not 0 farenheit...wtf?

                    • Redssracer
                      Redssracer  11 hours back

                      How about testing battery/battery corrosion cleaners

                    • yourleftnut1
                      yourleftnut1  12 hours back

                      Just bought an ever start battery. Works great

                    • wannab009
                      wannab009  12 hours back

                      Test these cheap inverters off ebay, https://www.ebay.com/itm/2000W-5000W-Car-LED-Power-Inverter-WATT-DC-12V-to-AC-110V-Converter/293062726005?ssPageName=STRK%3AMEBIDX%3AIT&var=591890780417&_trksid=p2060353.m1438.l2649

                    • SS454LS6
                      SS454LS6  12 hours back

                      Damn I used to ignore and shun Walmart batteries false assuming they were junk. Thank you Project Farm for teaching me facts!

                    • Rivera
                      Rivera  13 hours back

                      Can we just take the time to appreciate all the work this man puts on every video

                    • JustForKicks4.6
                      JustForKicks4.6  14 hours back

                      As a team member with Advance, I'm disappointed to see our silver not performing as well as it should. Though I would like to see testing with a silver and then a gold to see if the power frame grid technology actually makes a difference.

                    • Codeman785
                      Codeman785  14 hours back

                      Sooo for the price, Optima is trash

                      • Project Farm
                        Project Farm   58 minutes back

                        Lots of comments that Optima isn't as good as it was in the past

                    • pmailkeey
                      pmailkeey  15 hours back

                      2 Questions:

                      1. How do they compare with an Exide battery ?
                      2. Recharging - what was the charge current and voltage ? Setting a switch to 10A says nothing. To compare, you need to charge batteries at 14·6 volts for the hour - AND note the charging current - some will take more current and charge quicker.

                    • animeII
                      animeII  16 hours back

                      Interesting information for sure. How about "Which car battery is best when new?" There are a lot of factors that go into battery performance in the long term. One should place felt battery terminal washers over the 17mm and 19mm terminals to absorb battery mist that causes corrosion. Also spray the terminals with battery terminal spray. Rating battery terminal spray would be an interesting project for the farm.

                    • papichulohoy
                      papichulohoy  17 hours back

                      Love your video man, great job as always

                    • Andrea
                      Andrea  17 hours back

                      New batteries costs a ton of money cause of start&stop , they said it was good for consumption but then you have to change a super expensive battery ... this is ridicolous !!

                      • Clay Coates
                        Clay Coates  18 hours back

                        Wonderful test gives me information that i can use

                      • Will Hoon For Food
                        Will Hoon For Food  19 hours back

                        Next video: throwing them all into the ocean.

                      • Abyyss3344
                        Abyyss3344  19 hours back

                        Back 20 years ago, nothing and I mean nothing was better than a DieHard Battery. When cranking over our super high compression engines plus lasting through all the hard abuse, no other battery came close... most batteries barely made it to half their warranties, the DieHards always out lasted their warranties. I still would pick DieHard in above freezing conditions.

                        • Abyyss3344
                          Abyyss3344  15 hours back

                          Truly, thank you for all your work... I've been with your channel from nearly the start and appreciate all you have done, and done well/professionally.

                        • Project Farm
                          Project Farm   15 hours back

                          Thank you for the feedback

                      • gjp627
                        gjp627  20 hours back

                        perfect timing! I need to replace the Everstart battery I purchased in 2014. My load tester shows it to be good, I suspect it has a failing cell. This battery was purchased at Walmart in July 2014 with a 2 yr replacement warranty. Lasting 5 years in a car that has always on headlights is wonderful. you have shown me saving money on a Walmart battery was a good idea. Living in Michigan I need the cold-cranking amps. Thanks

                      • Jordan Reed
                        Jordan Reed  24 hours back

                        Thank you for all your hard work. Your videos are amazing and so educational. Thanks again!

                        • Jason Dority
                          Jason Dority  1 days back

                          Great test, but, every battery you got was a gold or premium series, except the carquest was a silver, there is a difference between there silver and gold series, I'd live to see what the gold would do against the others.

                          • The Duder
                            The Duder  1 days back

                            Another well done video! Expensive video too. lol
                            Apologies for the long comment. But you can always ignore it. lol
                            And good job on working smarter not harder. I still use electrical meters and math to determine resistance and actual current ratings. lol Should buy one of those testers I guess.
                            My theory on battery cost outside of the AGM cells:
                            People pay the prices. It's that simple.
                            If consumers lodged a protest and refused to purchase, prices would drop dramatically overnight. (applies to gas as well)
                            But in the battery market, consumers are usually left without a choice of protesting. Chances are their battery is dead, therefore they must buy one no matter what.
                            Manufacturers are WELL informed of this and fully take advantage of it.
                            Costs to manufacture drop every 5 years at least.
                            But they continuously raise prices.
                            In order to prevent over-pricing, laws must be submitted and voted for. But that runs a risk of effecting good ole' capitalism.
                            And that is what leaves us in the sinking boat known as greed driven price inflation.

                            AGM batteries on the other hand, you have to pay for the tech so to speak.
                            Their ability to be 80% discharged and recover is impressive.
                            And they can be charged very fast in comparison to flooded cells.
                            But beware when you use AGM. Not even joking.
                            Many vehicle charging systems have a fixed float charge of 14.4 volts. 2.4 volts per cell.
                            AGM demands a lower float charge of 2.25 volts per cell, with 2.30 volts being max.
                            They can be damaged easily by overcharging. A long drive can be enough to cook the battery.
                            My gas hypothesis that can be considered a testable theory:
                            If everyone simply filled their tanks on a given day and did NOT buy ANY gas on the following day, by the 3rd day, gas prices would be around $1.50 a gallon at most.
                            We all could buy 10,000 gallons all in one day, but as long as no gas purchases occurred the following day, those companies would literally freak and prices would plummet.
                            Those companies operate on a daily basis. Meaning their profits MUST be above a certain level each day no matter what. One day of no fuel purchases places them tens of MILLIONS below their acceptable profit margin.
                            They would bend to our will like a wet noodle.
                            Even just planning such an event would cause them to drop prices. Even if it is impossible to get everyone to do one simple thing at the same time on the same day. lol

                            • Wesley Carroll
                              Wesley Carroll  1 days back

                              Could you test a Duracell from Sam's Club?

                            • 1DjScarface
                              1DjScarface  1 days back

                              Dose the quality ratings carry over to GROUP 65 batteries??

                              Do the after market batteries next...

                            • david HADLEY
                              david HADLEY  1 days back

                              Thanks again for your insight, your the real deal.

                            • Waylon Dicken
                              Waylon Dicken  1 days back

                              This is my favorite channel and this would've been my all time favorite comparison and most useful, if you would have used the (Advance) Autocraft Gold Series, which is the only battery anyone in my family has bought the last 10-15 years. I still found it very informative, although I thought the end result was to determine the best battery on the market. So I guess i will probably give the Walmart brand a go next time around and see for myself. I'm sorry if this had already been answered , as I did try to scroll through the comments to check,, but 8,200 if them is a little too time consuming. Still, i greatly appreciate all the time spent and work you do on here!!!

                            • squee222
                              squee222  1 days back

                              The "volt increase" metric for how fast a battery charges is useless as each battery has a different charge discharge curve and it won't be linear. Since your starting the batteries at different charge levels this is pretty meaningless information.

                            • Gary R
                              Gary R  1 days back

                              Will Epson salt restore a completely dead car battery ?

                            • keantoken
                              keantoken  1 days back

                              We had a Walmart Everstart battery that just died after something like 2 years. At the end it would always under charge and then occasionally would discharge to 8V within a few hours. No battery drain from the car, and the problem went away when we got a new battery.

                            • Robert Nirenberg
                              Robert Nirenberg  1 days back

                              Video Idea: Evaporust vs WD-40 rust remover vs Menard's house brand remover vs any others you could find.

                            • Austin Blair
                              Austin Blair  2 days back

                              I don’t know if you were going for batteries in the same price range or straight performance. I work for advanced and I just thought it was unfair to compare our lowest end battery to competitors nicer batteries that cost more. I would’ve liked if you compared using our gold or even platinum for comparison sake.

                              • Project Farm
                                Project Farm   1 days back

                                Thank you for the feedback. The local Advance didn't have the "gold" in stock for this group size.

                            • Dennis Jemison
                              Dennis Jemison  2 days back

                              Needed new batts for my 06 ram 5.9 and Walmart was out of stock so went to o'reilly and got the super start batts and so far great batteries 1 yr old. I use a battery maintainer on my truck as it will sit for a few weeks at a time without use to save the battery drain from the ecm etc. My last batts lasted from 08 to dec 18. hope these batts give me another 10 years? God Bless & Great Video!!!

                              • michael montgomery
                                michael montgomery  2 days back

                                Anybody need anything? I gotta make a Walmart run.

                                • robert tuttle
                                  robert tuttle  2 days back

                                  I’d like to see u test flash lights. LETS FINE OUT.

                                • EGGINFOOLS
                                  EGGINFOOLS  2 days back

                                  Awesome test. I would like to see how a OEM battery right out of the dealer would do. My AC Delco battery lasted 15 years in my 03 sierra

                                • LupenSLO
                                  LupenSLO  2 days back

                                  I am from Europe and never heard of group size, cranking amps and cold cranking amps on a car battery...buu

                                • Chris Rogers
                                  Chris Rogers  2 days back

                                  Walmart was rated a top battery by consumer reports years ago. I started buying them instead of batteries from advance auto. The last two batteries I purchased from Walmart didn't last 6 months. This is something that interest me considering all the batteries i have to purchase for our company every year. I'm curious why an interstate battery wasn't tested, it seems to be pretty popular with auto care centers.

                                • ToughAncientSpark
                                  ToughAncientSpark  2 days back

                                  When I worked at an RV dealership, the local independent battery rep told us there are only four different battery manufacturers in the U.S. All they change is the labels.

                                • Water Lily channel
                                  Water Lily channel  2 days back

                                  Battery made to use for two years only..sure...hahaha

                                • quintin raymond
                                  quintin raymond  2 days back

                                  Duralast is the best option, AutoZone has best warranties and no hassle if you need to use warranty.

                                • Amazing Syed
                                  Amazing Syed  2 days back

                                  Who else think he looks like Steve Jobs

                                  • Sam Sonn
                                    Sam Sonn  2 days back

                                    Great breakdown on the Johnson controls and East Penn

                                  • David Goodwin
                                    David Goodwin  2 days back

                                    I am very impressed with your presentations and your code of ethics. Thank you for doing this.